Old Forester Birthday Bourbon is one of those annual releases that bourbon enthusiasts eagerly anticipate, and the 2026 edition certainly makes a memorable first impression. The nose is absolutely spectacular, setting expectations sky-high. In this review, we will find out if the palate delivers on the promise of that remarkable aroma.

Nose
Fantastic! Burnt sugar, crème brûlée–covered cherries, char, and aged, seasoned oak layered with brown sugar. Velvety vanilla cream mingles with baking spices, creating an exceptionally dense and rich aroma. This is easily one of the best nosing experiences I've had in a very, very long time.
Palate
Dry oak, brown sugar, and a touch of honey sweetness, accompanied by a slightly thin mouthfeel. Frankly, it's a little disappointing given how spectacular the nose is. Some of the richer, sweeter characteristics become more pronounced with each sip, but the overall experience remains somewhat one-dimensional. However, after letting this open up a couple of weeks, the palate gets sweeter and more balanced.
Old Forester Birthday Bourbon 2026 is good, almost very good, but at $200 MSRP, I expect more.
Finish
Surprisingly long, especially considering the 97 proof and relatively thin palate. Dry oak and tobacco linger, providing a pleasant, oak-forward conclusion.
Overall
The 2026 Old Forester Birthday Bourbon is a bit of a mixed bag. The nose is nothing short of extraordinary, but the palate struggles to live up to it. There's certainly quality here, and I appreciate the seasoned oak influence, but I was expecting more depth, richness, and complexity from a bourbon at this price point.
If I were judging this bourbon strictly by its nose, it would be among the best I've experienced in years. Unfortunately, the palate brings it back down to earth.