Review of Penelope Straight Bourbon Whiskey (Classic Series) 92 Proof

The first thing I noticed about this first pour of Penelope Straight Bourbon Whiskey (Classic Series) was the color. For a bourbon with an MSRP of around $44.99, it's surprisingly dark. It's uncommon to see this level of color density at this price point, suggesting either a healthy amount of barrel influence or well-selected blending. It's an impressive first impression.

Nose

The nose is soft, inviting, and unmistakably baking spice-forward. Cinnamon and nutmeg lead the way, supported by vanilla and a touch of rye spice that adds just enough lift without overpowering the sweeter aromas. With a little time in the glass, the oak begins to emerge, adding another layer of depth.

Palate

The palate caught me by surprise with a burst of honeyed sweetness that quickly gives way to a baking spice-driven profile featuring black pepper and nutmeg. There are also notes of brown sugar and a measured amount of dry oak, which provides welcome structure and balance. That dry oak is particularly impressive for a bourbon at this price point. At 92 proof, it drinks slightly warmer than expected, delivering a satisfying kick that many bourbon enthusiasts will appreciate. The mouthfeel is medium-bodied with a pleasant coating texture that carries the spice well across the palate. Penelope Straight Bourbon Whiskey (Classic Series) is definitely a bourbon for those who enjoy baking spice-forward profiles. I judge everything neat, but this is absolutely the type of bourbon I would reach for when making cocktails because its spice character should stand up exceptionally well in classics like an Old Fashioned or Manhattan.

Finish

The finish is medium in length, with the baking spices lingering alongside the dry oak. While not an overly long finish, the warmth continues to build in the chest and lasts noticeably longer than I would expect from a 92-proof bourbon.

Conclusion

I am pleasantly surprised by this first pour of Penelope Straight Bourbon Whiskey (Classic Series) and it mashbill of 78% Corn, 10% Rye, and 12% Barley Malt. It delivers a classic, well-balanced bourbon profile with enough spice and oak to keep it interesting while remaining approachable. If Penelope can maintain this level of consistency with this exoression, it will be formidable competition in the under-$60 bourbon market.